Ohio high schools will vote next spring on a proposal that could dramatically change the state’s postseason athletic tournaments by separating public and private schools into different divisions.
The Ohio High School Athletic Association announced Wednesday that it has received a completed petition requiring a statewide referendum vote among its member schools in May 2027.
The proposal, submitted by several public schools from the Suburban League in Northeast Ohio, received the required number of signatures from member school principals to force a vote.
If approved, public and private schools would compete in separate postseason tournament divisions beginning with the 2028-29 school year.
The OHSAA currently has 813 member high schools, including 691 public schools and 121 nonpublic schools, according to the association.
Voting will take place May 1-15, with each member high school principal casting one vote on behalf of their school. A simple majority is required for passage.
“This issue has come up several times in the history of the OHSAA and our schools will vote on it again next May,” OHSAA Executive Director Doug Ute said.
Ute acknowledged differences between public and private schools but expressed concerns about the potential consequences of separating postseason competition.
“Are there differences between public and private schools? Yes, but we believe that separate tournaments would have some negative unintended consequences,” Ute said.
The proposal would represent a significant change to Ohio high school athletics.
If approved, the OHSAA Board of Directors would determine the number of tournament divisions for public and private schools in each sport.
The proposal would also eliminate the state’s existing competitive balance system, which adjusts tournament classifications based on factors beyond traditional school enrollment.
Ohio voters within the OHSAA have rejected similar proposals twice before.
In 1978, a proposal to separate public and private school tournaments failed by a vote of 83.9% to 16.1%. Another attempt in 1993 was defeated 66.8% to 33.2%.
Currently, eight states have some form of separate postseason tournaments for public and private schools.
Competitive balance system could be eliminated
Ohio’s competitive balance system was approved by member schools in 2014 and implemented during the 2017-18 school year.
The system uses varsity roster information to adjust tournament division assignments in football, soccer, girls volleyball, boys and girls basketball, baseball and softball.
According to the OHSAA, public schools won 56% of state championships in those sports between the 2001-02 and 2016-17 school years, compared with 44% for private schools.
Since competitive balance was implemented, public schools have won 66% of state championships in those sports, while private schools have claimed 34%.
Ute said the association continues to evaluate the system and believes additional discussion is needed before making such a significant change.
“Competitive balance has an impact in those sports and we continue to study that process to see if there is more than can be done,” Ute said.
He also warned that separating the schools could create divisions with relatively few private schools and significant enrollment differences between competing programs.
The OHSAA plans to hold a series of meetings with member schools in early 2027 to explain the proposal, address questions and discuss the potential impact on postseason competition.
The final decision will rest with the association’s member schools when voting begins in May.









